Are lookaleicas now better than Leicas? Fuji X100s, Panasonic GX7.

All above - Panasonic GX7 Olympus 45mm f/1.8

All above - Fuji X100s

I wonder if anyone, in a blind test, could tell a Leica file from that of any other camera these days. Sharper? More colour depth? Obviously better image quality? Well, I'm pretty sure I couldn't and in many cases I may well prefer the non-Leica image. In my original piece on the Leica T, I wrote about the possibility of getting style AND content. Well lots of the first, but the second? Well not for me.

A non-M Leica that takes M-mount lenses without focus peaking, an ageing Sony 16MP sensor and forced touch-screen control with a screen that is seemingly no better than any other in bright sunlight hardly gets my pulse racing. What will Leica's middle-aged + traditionalist customer base makes of this? Will the young turks who champion camera tech., wi-fi and the like take out second mortgages and sell kidneys to buy the Leica T? Is this just a pretty ordinary 16MP APS-C camera in a show pony exterior? Well unfortunately that may be the case.

When the Leica X-Vario was announced, despite all the criticism, I knew I wanted one. It was right for me. And I liked the X-Vario, I liked it a lot, but now I have the Fuji X100s and I like that better. In fact a lot better. And Fuji make classy cameras and classy lenses that are every bit as good as the Leica M9, X1, X2, X-Vario and Leica lenses I've owned. And they don't cost ridiculous amounts of money. Hand made in Germany? Well OK, but Fuji seem to get the same quality machine made in Japan. And it costs a lot less. 

To justify their price Leicas have to be special, but it seems to me that the Leica T, despite it's superb styling just isn't that special. I know what this sensor is like and I've looked at the samples and they seem awfully familiar. Just like the X1, X2 and X-Vario. The point being that I can get that same quality elsewhere. Much as it pains me to have to say it, I think Leica have lost the plot. For whatever reason they seem to think that they have to compete with the likes of Sony, Panasonic and Fuji. 

And if they want to do touchscreen, wi-fi and all the other current camera tech. then they surely have to do it better than it seems the T can produce, because this is an area where Sony and Panasonic in particular are very strong. A shame, for a while there I was hopeful, but I suspect that my love affair with the red dot is distinctly cooling. And after reading the full specs yesterday afternoon I went out shooting with my Fuji X100s and Panasonic GX7 + Olympus 45mm f/1.8 and began to think the heretical. That lookaleicas are indeed now better than Leicas themselves. And I wouldn't have predicted that. Leica aren't the ones to aspire to anymore as far as I'm concerned and the more Andreas Kauffman drags them in the direction they are going, the less I like it. 

Will it be succesful? Who knows. However as far as I'm concerned there are much more interesting and useful alternatives. When I first saw the images of the Leica T I reorganised my camera shelf thinking of what I could sell to buy one. I even put a couple of cameras on ebay. Well those cameras are now no longer for sale and the shelf is back looking like it did before. And no one-piece aluminium body, no matter how sexy it looks, is likely to alter that.

All original material on this blog is © Soundimageplus.  Please Respect That  

Please note that opinions expressed in this blog are just that, opinions. What is written here is at no time intended as a recommendation or otherwise of photographic gear or practice. This is a personal blog written 'in the moment' and is primarily intended as an entertainment. I would also point out that this is not a review site and not intended to be so and the Google+ groups where you can post comments are not forums. I am the sole moderator and I will remove any post (and poster) if I think fit. 

Plus the Soundimageplus blog is 100% independent. No-one sends me gear to review and I have no relationship with any manufacturer or retail outlet. I buy all the gear I use and write about. The advertisements that appear on this site are generated by Google and I have no control over the content, which differs from country to country. I do make a small income from them, which covers expenses and some small recompense for the time I take to write this, but no more than that. If you like what you read and would like to help me to continue to keep buying stuff to write about then clicking on a few adds will earn me a few fractions of a penny. It will cost you nothing and you don't have to buy anything to contribute a (very!) small amount to my coffers.  

N.B. to see more on the cameras and lenses featured in this post click on the relevant labels (tags and keywords) at the bottom of this post.

For commenting, discussion, posting your pictures, links and articles - join the Soundimageplus Blog Readers Group on Google+ 
follow on tumblr   
soundimageplus blog readers pictures group on flickr
soundimageplus on YouTube  
soundimageplus on Vimeo